CHAPTER 4

A Reason to Stay

7 min read October 24, 2026

Adam answered on the fourth ring.

“I found a letter from him,” Nora said.

There was a pause.

“Thomas?”

“It was inside a book.”

“Have you read it?”

“Yes.”

She waited for him to ask what it said. Instead, he asked, “Would you like me to come over?”

Nora looked at the empty shop.

“Yes.”


He arrived carrying a loaf of bread in a paper bag.

“I was buying supper.”

“You keep bringing food.”

“You keep forgetting it.”

She showed him the letter.

He read it at the counter, his coat still on.

“Peter gave him her note on Sunday,” he said.

“And he waited until nearly seven.”

“So she might only just have missed him.”

Nora nodded.

She had spent the last twenty minutes arranging events into different sequences, each one ending in the same place.

“He thought she’d chosen to stay,” she said. “She thought he knew about her father and had left anyway.”

Adam turned the page over.

“‘I thought you knew why.’”

“Yes.”

“Did she write that for him?”

“I don’t know. Perhaps she was trying out what to say.”

“On the back of his letter?”

“There are ten unsent ones downstairs. Apparently she wasn’t short of paper.”

He smiled faintly, then set the letter down.

“I can ask my aunt about Peter.”

“Is he still alive?”

“No. But she might remember something.”

Nora rubbed her eyes.

“Yesterday I thought we were finding a love story.”

“We are.”

“It’s mostly people making assumptions.”

“That sounds fairly recognisable.”

She laughed, although she didn’t quite want to.

Adam lifted the paper bag.

“Bread?”


They ate upstairs, with June’s leftover casserole warmed in a saucepan because Nora couldn’t find a suitable dish.

Adam found one immediately.

“How?”

“People usually keep them near the oven.”

“I work in a museum. I’m accustomed to labels.”

“I’ll write you some.”

They sat opposite each other at the kitchen table.

Across the harbour, lights appeared in the windows above the shops. Nora had watched those same windows as a child, inventing lives for the people behind them.

Now she wondered whether somebody was looking back.

“Tell me about the exhibition,” Adam said.

She looked up.

“What?”

“The one you’re going back for.”

For the next ten minutes, she explained.

It was a small exhibition about everyday objects carried across borders: a sewing case, a cooking pot, photographs wrapped in a scarf. Nora had spent months working with families on what they wanted visitors to know.

“One woman brought her father’s radio,” she said. “We were all very careful about asking what it represented.”

“And?”

“She said it represented thirty years of him refusing to buy a better radio.”

Adam laughed.

“That’s good.”

“It is. We kept her exact words.”

She found a photograph on her phone and passed it across the table.

He studied the case layout.

“You made this?”

“With other people.”

“But this is your work.”

“Yes.”

He looked up.

“You sound different when you talk about it.”

“How?”

“As though you know where everything goes.”

Nora took the phone back.

“That would surprise the installation team.”

“I didn’t mean the objects.”

She concentrated on cutting her bread.

“What about your workshop?”

“What about it?”

“Show me.”

“It’s currently a garage with poor lighting.”

“Then show me the garage.”


The following afternoon, Nora walked to Adam’s address carrying two coffees.

His workshop stood behind a narrow house on a street above the harbour. The side gate opened reluctantly.

A handwritten notice on the garage door read:

PLEASE KNOCK. MACHINES MAY BE RUNNING.

She knocked.

The sound inside stopped.

Adam opened the door wearing ear defenders around his neck.

“You found it.”

“I followed the smell of sawdust and financial uncertainty.”

“That’s the place.”

He stepped aside.

There was barely room to move between the workbench, stacked timber and furniture waiting for repair. A chair stood upside down under a clamp. Beside it, a chest of drawers had been stripped to pale wood.

The room smelled warm and clean.

Nora put the coffees on a clear patch of bench.

“This is beautiful.”

“The chest?”

“All of it.”

He looked around as though checking they were in the same garage.

“You should see it when I’m looking for a screwdriver.”

She moved closer to the chest of drawers.

One corner had been repaired with a carefully fitted piece of darker timber.

“Will you stain that to match?”

“A little. You’ll still be able to see the repair.”

“Why?”

“The owner asked me to keep it visible. Her father damaged it moving house. She remembers him apologising every time he opened the drawer.”

Nora ran a finger above the join without touching it.

“So that stays.”

“That stays.”

She turned towards him.

For a moment, neither spoke.

Then Adam picked up a small wooden tray from the bench.

“This is yours.”

“Mine?”

“It was upstairs in the shop. Your grandmother asked me to mend the handle.”

Nora recognised the painted blue flowers along its edge.

“She used to bring breakfast on this when I stayed.”

“I know.”

“She told you?”

“She said you insisted on being treated like a hotel guest.”

“I was seven.”

“Apparently the service was heavily reviewed.”

Nora laughed, then found she couldn’t quite stop.

When she did, her eyes were wet.

Adam set the tray down.

“I’m sorry.”

“No. Don’t be.”

He waited while she found a tissue in her pocket.

“I keep finding parts of her that other people got to keep,” she said.

“You have parts we don’t.”

“I should have visited more.”

He leaned against the bench.

“I can’t tell you how often you should have visited.”

She looked at him.

“But she talked about you,” he said. “Often. The museum. Your flat. The time you tried to repair your own washing machine.”

“That story was supposed to stay private.”

“She was very proud that you knew when to call somebody.”

Nora wiped beneath one eye.

“She made that sound like an achievement?”

“With considerable effort.”


They walked back towards the harbour carrying the tray between them.

At the corner, Adam’s phone rang.

“My aunt,” he said, looking at the screen.

Nora stopped beside a closed flower shop.

Adam listened for a while, asking only two questions.

“When did he tell you?”

Then, “Are you sure those were his words?”

When he ended the call, his expression was thoughtful.

“Peter delivered a note from Elsie,” he said. “Before the station meeting.”

“We knew that.”

“He told Thomas her father was ill and she probably wouldn’t be coming.”

“But Thomas went anyway.”

“Yes.”

Nora watched a bus turn into the next street.

“Then why write that he wished she’d told him herself?”

“Because she hadn’t. Peter had.”

“And she thought Peter had explained properly.”

“Probably.”

“What did your aunt say?”

“That Peter thought he was being helpful. He told her years later that they’d both made a terrible fuss over one missed train.”

Nora let out a slow breath.

A man who considered the matter finished had stood between two people waiting for more.

“Did Thomas ever go back?”

“Once. A few months later.”

“To see Elsie?”

Adam nodded.

“Peter told him she was seeing someone.”

“My grandfather.”

“Possibly.”

“Possibly,” Nora repeated.

They resumed walking.

There was nobody left who could give them every answer.

She was beginning to understand how much she had expected from a bundle of letters.


Outside the shop, Adam took the tray while Nora unlocked the door.

The fish-shaped bell rang above them.

“Tea?” she asked.

“I should get back.”

“Right.”

He stepped inside to put the tray on the counter.

Nora stood beside the open door.

“I don’t want to make their mistake,” she said.

Adam turned.

She could feel herself preparing a joke, something that would let her retreat without embarrassment.

She let it pass.

“I’d like to have dinner with you. Somewhere neither of us has to repair anything.”

He smiled.

“Yes.”

“Good.”

“Tomorrow?”

“Tomorrow.”

He came towards her, stopping close enough that she could see the fine sawdust caught in the seam of his sleeve.

“Can I kiss you?”

“Yes,” Nora said.

The kiss was brief. His hand rested lightly against her cheek, and she found herself catching the front of his coat when he began to step away.

The second kiss lasted longer.

When they separated, the shop door was still open.

A woman passing with a terrier gave them an interested glance.

Nora closed it.

Adam laughed softly.

“I’ll book somewhere.”

After he left, she carried the tray upstairs and set it on the kitchen table.

Her phone was ringing.

The estate agent’s name filled the screen.

Nora answered.

“I have someone keen to view,” the woman said. “Cash buyer. They can come tomorrow afternoon, if that suits.”

Nora looked down at the repaired handle.

Only that morning, an offer had been the thing she was waiting for.

“Yes,” she said at last. “Tomorrow afternoon.”

When the call ended, she opened Adam’s message thread.

She typed that the window was still working beautifully.

Then she deleted it.

The estate agent has arranged a viewing tomorrow. I wanted you to hear it from me.

She sent the message and left the phone on the table.

Every chapter opens another door.